How to Design a BGA in PCB for Manufacturability and Cost

A ball grid array (BGA) is an advanced IC packaging technique that connects the silicon die to a PCB through an array of solder balls on the bottom of the package. BGAs offer several benefits over earlier packaging styles but need careful PCB design considerations for reliability, assembly yield and cost control. This article provides key guidelines to implement BGA footprints effectively covering: BGA benefits and construction PCB land pattern design Routing and plane split rules Thermal and mechanical analysis Manufacturing and inspection Cost optimization Following these chip-package co-design best practices results in robust, high-yielding and cost-effective BGA implementation. BGA Package Overview

BGA package showing solder ball array below encapsulated silicon die A BGA uses an array of solder balls that connect to the PCB directly eliminatingfragile leads of earlier packaging. Some benefits over older styles: Compact footprint fits more I/Os in same area Electrical performance superior due to shorter connects Robust against mechanical handling issues Facilitates efficient PCB routing with access between balls But BGA assembly depends critically on solder joint integrity. Optimized PCB design guides process reliability and manufacturability. Key Aspects of BGA PCB Design While the package construction defines electrical interfaces and footprint dimensions, PCB layout completion ensures assembly success through: 1. Escape Routing - Between tight ball pitches 2. Reference Planes - For signal integrity return paths 3. Mechanical Analysis - Solder joint stresses 4. Thermal Analysis - Power dissipation without hotspots 5. Test Access - Fear coverage of hidden joints 6. Renovation Ability - To support repairs or upgrades Getting these right speeds up product development while preventing field issues down the line. We explore PCB guidelines in detail now. 1. BGA Land Pattern Design Rules The PCB footprint or land pattern guides solder paste application and final joint shapes critical for reliability. Key aspects of land patterns: 1.1 Basic Pad Geometry Circular shaped pads work well for BGAs. They allow even wetting on all sides compared to rectangular pads. Pad size depends on ball diameter with typical ratios: Solder Mask Defined Pads: Pad size = 1.2 x Ball DiameterGives leeway for mask misregistration Non Solder Mask Defined: Pad size = 1 x Ball Diameter 1.2 Array Grid Design Pad spacing or pitch equals the ball pitch specified for the package usually 0.8mm to 1mm. Complete grid dimensions match package footprint. Check manufacturers recommendations Account for PCB fabrication tolerance 1.3 Pad Stenciling and Pastemask Stencil openings approx 20% larger than pads Adequate paste land coverage but no bridges 1.4 Number of Rows Extra rows help paste release besides multiplying joint count for power/signal transfer. Minimum 2 rows recommended with more for large units. 2. BGA Routing Practices While BGAs offer routing under the package, care is needed to prevent tombstoning especially with peripheral balls connecting to outer layers. Optimized BGA escape routing with vias Guidelines Plan number of layers considering ball pitch Use stacked and coax vias for each I/O trace escaping the ball pads Equalize trace lengths of differential pairs Implement length matching for timing critical signals Voids below BGA risk collapsed joints under load 3. Reference Plane Design Signal and power integrity needs uninterrupted reference planes under BGAs for controlled impedance transmission lines and noise isolation. Recommendations Place BGA over solid GND/PWR planes if possible Avoid plane cuts under component area Insert vertical stitching vias around pads Enclose BGA area between bounding plane pairs 4. Thermal Analysis Being enclosed structures with hidden joints, BGA cooling needs upfront analysis to sustain power levels. Thermal vias help lateral conduction of heat Guidelines Specify adequate copper heat spreaders/planes Add thermal vias for vertical conduction Define thermal pads linked to inner planes Extend GND plane around package as heat sink Confirm junction temperature limits after board level simulation 5. Mechanical Stress Analysis Due to CTE mismatch between silicon die, substrate, and PCB, thermal cycling strains solder joint reliability demanding modeling. Key Checks Estimate shear and bending momentum on outer balls Verify maximum stress locations Sweep temperature range from storage to operation Reflow simulation for process induced damage Mechanical analysis should meet IPC and JEDEC recommendations for robust BGA solder joints before release to production. 6. Design for Manufacturing Smooth manufacturing requires optimizing BGA placement and land patterns for assembly ergonomics. Guidelines Match land patterns to stencil, printer capability Sufficient clearance between BGAs for paste release Place fiducials for inspection points Verify reflow profile temperatures Characterize shear force limits for pick and place tooling Sample rework process using hot air or infrared 7. Design for Test Access While electrical validation of hidden solder joints poses challenges, we can enhance test coverage through: X-ray imaging of BGA to inspect internals ICT+flying probe testing at component side Embedded contact points for probes Special BGA test socket fixtures Detailed inspection quantifies process fitness before committing to full production. 8. Design for Reliability Environmental stresses degrade BGA solder joint integrity over product lifetime requiring derating. Key Factors Assess fatigue damage across use conditions Define expected service loads - thermal, mechanical shock/vibration Component mounting process optimization - minimize voiding Material selection - substrates, underfill where necessary Qualification criteria - drop test, temperature cycling A robust reliability testing and qualification approach proves out the BGA implementation prior to market introduction. Cost Considerations for BGA Design While absolutely necessary for complex ICs, BGAs impact fabrication, assembly and test costs which we should optimize: 1. Layer Count More layers add infrastructure yet enable routing. Find knee of curve. 2. Panel Utilization Effect of larger package on board footprint density. 3. Viability of Rework/Replace Manual soldering options versus full SMT mixes. 4. Inspection Expenses Manual visual checking versus x-ray costs. 5. Qualification Investment Field return risks versus accelerated testing. By balancing functionality needs, quality targets and budgetary constraints effective BGA cost management gets feasible. Summary of BGA PCB Design Considerations In closing, here is a checklist covering key aspects that influence successful BGA implementation - technical factors plus cost: Land Pattern: Pad diameter, stencil openings and paste volumes Routing: Layer planning, track lengths, impedance control Planes: Uninterrupted references below component Thermal: Sufficient copper heat sinks, thermal vias Mechanical: Model shear stresses, anchor to prevent tombstoning Inspectability: Fiducials, test points to contact solder joints Qualification: Standards based reliability testing Rework: Manual soldering, hot air equipment Cost: Panel utilization, yield influencers, test investment Getting these facets right from prototype to production ensures volume manufacturing quality and customer satisfaction.

How Much Does It Cost To Get A PCB Assembled?

 In addition to bare board fabrication expenses, stuffing a printed circuit board with components (often termed PCB assembly or PCA) carries its own set of costs driven by factors such as component selections, processing technologies, testing needs, and order quantities. This article examines typical assembly pricing models and what elements influence cost when building populated boards.

PCB Assembly Cost Structure

The total cost quoted by an electronics manufacturing services (EMS) provider or contract assembler generally contains both fixed and variable elements:

Typical PCB Assembly Quote Elements

• NRE Charges
• Tooling & Programming
• Test Fixture Building
• Process Engineering
• Bill of Materials Optimization
• Component Material Costs
• Variable Processing Charges
• Solder Paste Printing
• Pick & Place Machine Setup
• Solder Reflow
• Cleaning
• Inspection & Testing
• Packaging & Handling

The non-recurring expenses (NREs) tied to project initiation represent fixed overhead costs independent of order volume, while the assembly process steps themselves scale in pricing with quantity. Understanding this fundamental divide is key to estimating budgets.

NRE Charges

Upfront NREs include charges for production preparation spanning:

Assembly Programming

Machine data instructions must be coded to guide automated pick-and-place arm movements, component rotations, and sequence priorities tailored to board layouts. Each new board generally requires several hours of dedicated programming for optimal efficiency.

Test Fixture Building

Any fixture hardware needed to interface boards with in-circuit test stations or functional validation equipment to confirm assembly correctness must be custom built for new board designs. Simple clamshell test points may suffice, but complex boards require mating connectors, pogo adapters, isolation buffers, etc.

Tooling Adjustments

Tweaks to factory equipment like stencils, tray holders, panel frames, and other tooling elements impacted by board dimensions often require updates when switching designs. Mechanical, pneumatic, vacuum, and electrostatic adjustments may be necessary. New stencils are common requirements.

Engineering Analysis

Prior to full scale ramp-up, assembler engineering teams analyze schematics, layouts, BOMs, fabrication/assembly documentation, and early prototypes to tailor processes specific for each board product. Potential issues need identification, equipment evaluations are completed, and process qualification builds conducted.

While NRE charges seem high compared to small assembly batches, these expenses get amortized over total production volume, dropping effective overhead costs per board at volume. For complex boards, NREs can easily exceed $10k, while simpler boards may require just a few $k upfront. NRE pricing should be clarified in quotations before proceeding.

Component Costs

The bill of materials (BOM) makeup dictated by board schematics primarily drives total components cost, but contract assemblers can suggest alternate parts with better pricing at volume.

BOM Line Item Pricing

Both material and unit charges per BOM line item factor into pricing. Standard small passives or generic actives can be less than a few cents, while advanced semiconductors, FPGAs, RF chips range over $10–100+ driving overall assembly pricing higher even when ignoring placement or soldering charges.

Reel Quantities

Larger reel component packaging further reduces per part cost but may have higher minimum order quantities (MOQs). If BOM optimization supported, shifting towards reeled components lowers overall materials cost.

Customer Supplied Parts

Rather than having assemblers procure all BOM elements, supplying fixed configurations or high cost parts yourself avoids excessive material markups while guaranteeing authentic components are used. This asset management must be weighed against internal overhead expenses.

Board Complexity Factors

In addition to materials themselves, physical PCB attributes also determine assembly process pricing between loading, soldering, cleaning, inspection etc process steps.

Placement Density

Component packing density set by board layout complexity pushes pick-and-place cycle times higher and risks occasional misseddrops. Higher density may force slower precision machine vision alignment steps during loading as well. Expect pricing premiums above roughly 100 components per square inch depending on part pitches.

Odd Components

Special support tooling for loading small passives like 01005 chips or handling tall connectors adds process considerations or external hand tooling tasks compared to standard 0603/0402 SMT parts, increasing placement pricing.

Double Sided Loading

Needing to stuff components on both top and bottom surfaces requires flipping boards and running through SMT lines twice, driving cost 2x higher compared to single sided placement. Reduce layer count if feasible during design to avoid.

Through Hole Parts

Leaded through hole parts demand separate insertion steps compared to sole SMT loading. While automatable, these extras process steps add cost. Some mixed technology boards may unavoidably require a small number of connectors or pins.

Solder Types

Lead-free SAC alloys are now standard, but some boards still rely on tin-lead solders. Any secondary solder pots or paste printing setups impinge on line changeover and reduce throughput driving cost upwards.

Selective Depanelization

Singulation routers cut assembled panels into individual PCBs. Skipping V-scoring depanelization early on keeps material utilization high but requires manually separating completed boards later when panels hold components. This risks damage without proper fixtures.

Testing and Inspection

Stringent testing protocols guarantee assembly quality but rack up expenses through capital equipment demands and reductions in process parallelization.

Visual AOI

Automated optical inspection (AOI) scanning looks for missing or skewed parts, solder defects, and other assembly flaws using pattern recognition algorithms after reflow stages. Typical 2D inspection suffices for many boards under $0.01 per capture, while more sophisticated 3D AOI costs multiply higher but captures finer defects that impact reliability statistics.

ICT Probing

Rigorous probing of nets validates end-to-end connectivity across all nodes by electrically checking shorts/opens down to component pin resolution. Bed of nails test fixtures required for ICT probing usually exceed $5k in custom tooling costs alone before validation charges tally upwards of $0.05 per net probed, easily eclipsing base assembly charges.

Functional Testing

Exercising critical interfaces or validating proper firmware operation requires development of custom test scripts plus any associated test equipment. Functional test creation itself can run $100 per hour between testbench development, debugging, and documentation for complex parallel testers. Per board functional test execution pricing in smaller volumes then range from $2.50-$25+ impacting small batch pricing dramatically. But this drops to under $0.10 at high volumes with test set amortization.

X-Ray Inspection

X-ray imaging used for BGA/CSP packages and multi-layer boards ensures hidden solder joint or via quality. Typical snapshot inspection costs around $5 per board for standard resolution. Then full multi-angle laminography can run upwards of $50–100 per analysis during new product introduction.

Economies of Scale

Assembly pricing is not strictly linear with ordered quantity due to improved efficiencies from batch processing and equipment utilization at volume production scales. Cost per board drops dramatically above ~500+ units.

Assembly Cost Per Board vs Volume

Order QuantityPrice per BoardAssembly Location1–50 boards$50 — $500+Local CM or Self50–250 boards$10 — $50Southeast Asia250–1,000 boards$5 — $25China1,000–5,000 boards$2 — $15China5,000–25,000 boards< $10China

Capital equipment like pick-and-place machines or reflow ovens cost upwards of $250k. Fully burdening monthly lease financing, maintenance, and depreciation of this machinery over small prototype runs drastically inflates price. But by batching even medium scale volumes, fixed expenses are amortized lowering assembly pricing exponentially. Approaching 25,000+ boards brings further discounts finally flattening around $2.50 per board. Even domestic assembly quotes can compete if volumes exceed 50k monthly boards.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main cost drivers?

BOM component costs, density/complexity factors impacting process tooling, degree of testing/inspection validation, and overall order volumes dictate assembly pricing. NRE charges also represent substantial fixed overheads.

What hidden costs might not be obvious?

Seemingly minor custom process steps like selective wave soldering, depanelization, QFN rework, or special storage/handling requirements rack up expenses not always clear from initial pricing guides. Clarify any unusual fabrication notes that carry through to assembly needs.

What quantity minimizes assembly cost?

Amortizing equipment investments and support staffing expenses over total throughput pushes assembled pricing exponentially lower above roughly 500 boards to approach $5 per board at median volumes with circuits of mid complexity. Further scaling keeps reducing unitary pricing down towards $2–3.

THE ULTIMATE GUIDE TO XILINX FPGA, SERIES, AND ALL DETAILS
https://ebics.net/xilinx-fpga/

How Blind Vias PCB Impacts Electronics Manufacturing
https://hillmancurtis.com/blind-vias-pcb/

How Blind Vias PCB Impacts Electronics Manufacturing
https://hillmancurtis.com/blind-vias-pcb/

What are the Features and Applications of the Xilinx Spartan 6 FPGAs?
https://ebics.net/xilinx-spartan-6-fpga/

What are the Features and Applications of the Xilinx Spartan 6 FPGAs?
https://ebics.net/xilinx-spartan-6-fpga/

What's Flexible PCB Role in Electronic Industry ?
https://hillmancurtis.com/flexible-pcb/

Introduction to FPGA programming and its Role in Computing
https://www.raypcb.com/fpga-programming/

BENEFITS OF CONSIDERING PCBA CONTRACT MANUFACTURING
https://www.raypcb.com/pcba-contract-manufacturing/

What is NFC Antenna
https://www.raypcb.com/nfc-antenna/

What is NFC Antenna
https://www.raypcb.com/nfc-antenna/

FPGA vs. GPU vs. CPU: Which Is the Best Choice for Your Application?
https://www.raypcb.com/fpga-vs-gpu-vs-cpu/

Top 15 rigid flex PCB Manufacturers in the World
https://www.raypcb.com/rigid-flex-pcb-manufacturers/

Top 15 rigid flex PCB Manufacturers in the World
https://www.raypcb.com/rigid-flex-pcb-manufacturers/

Purple PCB-Outstanding and Attractive Circuit board
https://www.raypcb.com/purple-pcb/

Where to Buy Rogers RT Duroid 5880 Laminate
https://www.raypcb.com/rogers-rt-duroid-5880/

Where to Buy Rogers RT Duroid 5880 Laminate
https://www.raypcb.com/rogers-rt-duroid-5880/

A Quick Guide to Rogers AD300D Laminates
https://www.raypcb.com/rogers-ad300d-pcb/

A Quick Guide to Rogers AD300D Laminates
https://www.raypcb.com/rogers-ad300d-pcb/